I have a bag awning on my pop-up, and the optional Catalina awning on my Scamp
. The bag awning is easier for me to set up and does not have a gap between the awning and the camper. Unless I'm staying at one place for an extended time I rarely put the awning out, and even when I put it out I usually close it if we leave to ensure no winds kick up and cause any damage (We try for shady sites).
We also carry a separate screen room that we sometimes use and that provides a mobile shade plus rain/insect free zone.
If I were to order a Scamp
new, it would be a tough decision, but I would probably decide to not order the Scamp awning with my Scamp.