If you take the lights off and look under the sheet metal that may tell you the story as to whether or not you have a
Scamp or a
Love Bug. If its just hiding the holes from a bit larger
light that sat flush then perhaps it really is a
Scamp as registered.
The foam stuff around the door is a pain! Replaced mine a number of times until I gave up using it.
Scamp sells a D shaped stick on rubber gasket that they dont show on their online store that you need to call the 1-800 and ask for it (Thank Floyd for that big tip!). It works much better and looks better as well. You can buy the same stuff from an Auto parts place but the packages it comes in are usually not long enough to go around the whole door so you need to by two packages. The stuff from Scamp comes long enough to go around the door in one long run and then some so cheaper than buying two packages and wasting a bunch.