Quote:
Originally Posted by GatorCasita
I am just curious why you mention the Casita frame strength. I have looked at many, many threads about Casitas, and I have yet to find anyone who had problems due to a Casita frame not being strong enough (unless they had a wreck or ran off the road into a ditch).
Maybe if one were to tow the trailer over very rough unpaved roads it might matter. However, adding a generator (50 lb) to the tongue is very common. Adding a box with 30 lb in the back would pretty much balance the added tongue weight from the generator. Is there some frame problem that we do not know about???
|
Well Randy, This is just my take on the frame's construction. I agree that adding something that weighs roughly 50 Lbs isn't going to wreak havoc with anything, even on these 3" mild steel "C" channel frames, but I have seen instances where some people have really gone overboard adding additional loads like a 50 Lb. platform mounted over the
propane tanks and then putting an unnecessarily large 110 Lb. 3000 watt
generator on that, plus an electric tongue jack, spare fuel cans, etc. There's a limit as to how much is too much. And, as you mentioned, many people do take their trailers off-road, so the additional bouncing also sets up a lot of flexing and stress.
Casita frames are just barely adequate for their intended use, and adding too much "extras" on it compromises the minimal strength inherent with their design. If I ever had to replace my frame, it would be at least 4" thick-walled "C" channel, not the 3" that it comes with. There's a correlation between building a more robust, but heavier, trailer or keeping things at a bare minimum to keep the
weight down. It's all a compromise in design, function, and what they can get away with for the least cost to produce. They certainly aren't built for strength, and when they do crack, break and collapse, its usually right where the frame rails are bent inward, just at the front of the trailer shell, to form the "A" frame up front. Those bends really weaken the rail considerably, and there have been many structural failures caused by repeated flexing and metal fatigue. Just my 2 cents on it.