Kathleen, since you are on a site dedicated to Molded
Fiberglass travel trailers, which most all 17' or under are less than 3,000lbs, neither of your choices of "stick built" trailers fit our beliefs that an all molded
fiberglass construction is lighter in weight, more durable, and less prone to
leaks (except for the usual areas of
windows, and vents) since there are no seams (some are completely fiberglass and will have no structural wood to rot). Some brands of molded fiberglass travel trailers in Canada that you may want to look at are Escape and
Boler, or a small
Bigfoot, to give you an idea of what a molded fiberglass trailer looks like. Best of luck with your search.
Dave & Paula